A Year Without Kieran

On 27th February 2019 I lost my soulmate, and the love of my life. I still cannot quite believe that this lovely man has gone. Even now, a year later, I expect to see him walking into the sitting room, or rushing to open the front door for me before I can get my key into it (one of his favourite tricks, if he happened to see me coming up the path). His first utterance would invariably be “Baby”, with a long, drawn out first syllable. How I miss hearing that word.

Kieran was the sweetest, gentlest, most caring person I ever knew. He would put himself out to help others and often spent hours talking with people who just needed someone to listen. And he looked after me. I didn’t know I needed someone to look after me until he came into my life but Kieran did, and he did it selflessly and completely. In the past year I have had to get used to not having him around to look after me; and yet I hear him talking to me, advising me or telling me off (!) constantly. At least I still have that.

Being with Kieran was easy. I won’t say we never argued. We did; sometimes having blazing rows, but we always found our peace and equilibrium again very quickly. Sulking wasn’t natural to either of us. It was the comfortable, easy way in which we functioned that was so special. Although we were very different in many ways, we thought alike and often knew exactly what the other was thinking. Frequently, we would say exactly the same thing at the same time. Some of this was probably a result of living together for a long time but I think it was more than that. We had that special connection which really does only come about with one’s soulmate. I’d never experienced it before and I will always be grateful that I had it with Kieran.

There is so much that I miss about Kieran. I miss the laughter. We both made each other laugh, all the time. Sometimes it was unintentional and, if that was at Kieran’s expense, he would complain that I was a “meany.” If it was at my expense, he’d practically split his sides laughing. He discovered early on that it was very easy to make me jump and he would react gleefully when he did so. Then there were the times when he’d just be plain crackers. I lost count of the times when I’d be minding my own business and he’d suddenly appear doing some weird dance or weirdly arrayed. Trying to ignore him was pointless. He’d just keep doing it until he got a reaction.

I even miss the fact that he was a terrible tease. He knew how to wind me up, and did so frequently. When I eventually lost my rag, he’d immediately respond “just having a little josh baby!” How I wish he were here to wind me up now.

Kieran also had a mission. It was too deflate my ego whenever he felt it had become necessary. He was extremely good at taking the piss out of me and bringing me back down to earth. Always it was accompanied by that wonderful, cheeky smile. Ah, that smile. Sometimes I could be absolutely furious with him and then he’d smile at me. He used to infuriate me with his inability ever to put anything back in the same place. I’d be moaning under my breath (useless, because he had really good hearing and would hear my mumbling even from several rooms away), and he’d just say “you love me!” accompanying the utterance with a smile.

And, of course, I did love him. I loved him with every fibre of my being. I still do.

I am incredibly grateful to my family and to my wonderful friends who have helped me get through this last year. There have been times when I really haven’t known how I’m going to carry on but friends and family have always been there for me. I think there will, for the rest of my life, always be a part of me missing. Maybe that’s alright. To deny it would be somehow to deny the strength of my love for Kieran and the wonderful, blissful years we had together.

Kieran, my love, my life; you left us too, too soon. When I look up to the stars I see the brightest, twinkliest, most outrageous and most wonderful star of them all shining down on me, and on all that huge number of people who loved you and whom you’ve left behind (a number he was far too modest and self-effacing to realise was so great).

I wish you could come back to us, but I know you can’t. I hope you’re having fun, teasing people and telling terrible jokes up there. Rest in peace my beautiful man. Xxxxx

Sunday’s Concert for Kieran

Last Sunday we cried, laughed and sang and played our hearts out. All in honour of the most wonderful man I have ever had the fortune to have in my life.

St Mary’s Choir sang one of Kieran’s favourite Mass Settings: the Mass for Five Voices by William Byrd. He loved all three of Byrd’s Masses but particularly this one. Sadly, we rarely had enough tenors to perform it (it has two tenor parts) so it tended only to come out on tour. On Sunday, however, we had the marvellous number of six tenors as everyone who has been a part of the choir wanted to come together to sing in Kieran’s memory. And they sang splendidly. The sound was lovely and the phrasing just right. There wasn’t a cadence misplaced or untidy. Kieran would have loved it.

The choir also sang a wonderful setting of the In Paradisum, specially composed in Kieran’s memory by Ivan Moody and written on receiving the news of his death. It is a simple, haunting version of the plainsong melody and, sung at the end of the first half of the concert, brought the more reflective part of the programme to a fitting end.

It wasn’t all choral music, however. We were joined by lots of singer friends and by pianists and string players.

Christopher Weston played the opening movement of Beethoven’s Moonlight Sonata. I chose this piece because Kieran had learnt to play it and loved it. It was, of course, rather painful to listen to and brought tears to me eyes. I couldn’t help seeing Kieran sitting at the piano enjoying his music. Chris played it beautifully.

Later in the programme, we were immensely privileged to have Alan Bullard play three of his piano preludes; the middle one of which was composed specially in Kieran’s memory; again on hearing of his death. What a great set of pieces these are. I hope they will soon be published so that many more people can enjoy them. Kieran’s slow movement is particularly poignant and Alan proved that he is a great player in addition to being a fantastic composer.

Although Kieran wasn’t huge fan of the organ, he did love his Bach (more of that later) and it was a joy to hear Will Foster play BWV 650: Kommst du nun, Jesu herunter. This was probably the last time our lovely little Hey positiv organ would be played in concert here in St Mary’s (it’s going to a new home in Hertfordshire). Will played at the opening concert of the organ in 2015. There’s a rather good video of the organ’s construction with Will playing and which Kieran filmed and edited on the St Mary’s Choir Youtube channel. It was, therefore, particularly appropriate that Will played the only organ piece in the programme. What’s more, he played it with immense precision and feeling. It was a lovely moment of peace in a full concert. This photo was taken by Kieran at the inaugural concert. He loved the fact that we were both wearing pink ties!

Will and Colin at the Positiv

Katie Marriot sang Tchaikovsky’s wonderful Nyet tolko tot, kto with huge intensity. It was totally enthralling. I had to pretend not to know what the words meant or I would have been on the floor. I then had to pretend that I couldn’t speak German as Liz Roberts sang Strauss’ Morgen. It was beautiful and greatly enhanced by the obligato violin solo beautifully played by Megan Hill.

It was incredibly appropriate that Naomi Sturges was able to be with us to sing Britten’s setting of Waly Waly. Naomi really began her choral career with St Mary’s and Kieran had always been really fond of her. In fact, I remember him pouring cold water on her from the balcony above as she sunbathed in Scheggino some years ago. That’s just the sort of trick he liked playing on people of whom we was really fond. Naomi’s singing was stunning; particularly the pianissimo last verse, which held everyone spellbound.

Another young singer with a long association with St Mary’s is Esme Smith and I was delighted to introduced to La Belle Isabeau by Berlioz; a piece I’d never heard in my life. It has a small choral accompaniment and choir and soloist sang together in perfect synchronicity; something that is actually quite difficult to achieve in this piece. It was lovely to hear Esme’s new mezzo-soprano voice. Kieran would have thoroughly enjoyed the performance. I have a video of him and Esme making silly music together in Italy; something I’ve been unable to watch since Kieran’s death, but I will.

Incredibly, in the second half, we were treated to another new piece. This time, something completely different. This was a song, music and words, specially written and performed by Ben Gibbon. He accompanied himself on the guitar but was also joined by friends who had come along to create a string band. Kieran and Ben shared a love of Radiohead, Muse and Pink Floyd; the latter of which many listeners likened his song to.

The strings performed Bach’s Double Violin Concerto, with the soloists being Salomé Rateau and Megan Hill. I love this concerto and Kieran would have really enjoyed the performance. Bach was one of his favourite composers and he loved both singing and playing his music. We visited the Bach house in Eisenach (Bach’s birthplace) not once but three times; the last being just last summer. It was a place he loved; though he was disappointed to discover last summer that the amazing pod seats, in which one could listen privately to any piece of Bach one chose, had disappeared (as was I).

Our final singer friend was Chris Foster. He sang Soave sia il vento (Cosi) with Liz and Katie in part one but rather stole the show with his version of Flanders and Swann’s In the Bath. With this one song, we had gone from tears to laughter in the course of one evening. Chris’ final two verses…

I can see but one salvation from this ghastly Brexit farce
In the bath, in the bath
Just as long as there’s no Farage, Aaron Banks and that Rees-Mogg
In the bath, in the bath
They’ve pinned their hopes on Boris, he’s just a UK Trump
And Corbyn actually wants to leave, he really is a chump
If Vince Cable were more able then “No Deal” would be off the table
(and) in the bath, in the bath.
Our dear Kieran was a friendly soul who always made us laugh
(but maybe not) in the bath, in the bath
He really showed his best of all with his work for Maldon Festival
(but again, probably not) in the bath, in the bath
He loved his science fiction, Star Trek and that Dr Who,
In politics he was Remain, we wish that he could too
He certainly could wow us when he wore his daring yellow trousers
(but not) in the bath, in the bath.
In the Bath

Katie Marriot sang the wonderful tipsy song from la Périchole, which got us all the mood for the final piece. Every single performer squeezed onto the stage (all 45 of us, plus grand piano) to sing Libiamo from La Traviata. Kieran didn’t particularly like opera (always a bit of a sore point between us) but he did love a party and this finished the evening with a wonderful, joyful party atmosphere.

It was a quirky evening; just like Kieran. His naughty sense of humour would have been tickled by it. I’m pretty sure that, just as at his funeral, he would have been rather taken aback by the huge outpouring of love for him. But it was a wonderful way in which to keep his memory alive. I am so grateful to everyone who took part and gave their time free. Monies raised are being put towards a choral scholarship in Kieran’s name.

Thank you for your continued love and support. Keep on loving Kieran with me.

Keiran in Globo

“He’ll always be with you”

Keiran in GloboI

It’s three months to the day that you died. When I awoke this morning, I’d not registered the date but this un-looked for anniversary must be the reason why I’ve been crying so much today.

“He’ll always be with you” is a phrase that has been said to me on many occasions over the past three months. I have, at times, found it intensely irritating because, clearly, you are not with me. On today, of all days, it’s particularly clear that you are not here any longer. I do know, however, that things have changed and are changing.

As time has gone by, it’s true, as people told me it would be, that the tears have become less frequent. It’s also true that I’ve gradually been able to function in a more normal fashion. I’ve been busy and I’ve even found myself finding my enthusiasm for certain projects again. But confusing and conflicting thoughts occupy me constantly.

Being busy, and occupied in enjoyable pursuits is good, but it also generates feelings of guilt. Guilt that I am able to function without you. Guilt that you’ve not been at the forefront of my thoughts all the time.

At other times I find myself being overwhelmed by my loss. I miss you all the time, of course, but sometimes it is so overwhelming that the tears not only flow freely but with an almost unbearable intensity. When this happens, I have to give in to it. There’s no point in fighting it. Often, it’s triggered by having caught sight of a photo of you. The one accompanying this blog is so typical of you. That impish grin and silly pose is you to a “t”. I do wonder when I’ll be able to look at photos of you and remember the happy occasions on which they were taken. At present I have, for the most part, to avoid looking at them because they always upset me so much.

Is this all part of that phrase “he’ll always be with you”, I wonder? There are often times when I’m engaged in something completely absorbing and even then I have this underlying sense of loss. For instance, the weekend I got back from my first visit to Scheggino without you, I went immediately into three days of rehearsals, one of which was an exhausting three session day. Even then, for a good hour and a half or so as I was fully engaged in the rehearsal process, I felt myself close to tears. The same thing happened last weekend during an actual performance. I was watching my students perform the production that I’d spent the last semester working on with them. Even as I enjoyed the production and their achievement I had an overriding sense of sadness and of tearfulness.

So is this feeling of your being in my head somewhere what that phrase “he’ll always be with you” actually means? Is it, in fact, you being with me?

When you died it felt as though a real physical part of me had been ripped from me. We used to laugh over how often it was that we would say the same thing at exactly the same time. Often we didn’t even need to put things into words but we knew exactly what we were both thinking. We used to comment that, after living together and sharing our lives for so long, it was natural that we should think as one. I think that’s probably why the pain of losing you was so physical, so violent. That oneness was, and is, no-longer there.

“He’ll always be with you.” It’s odd that your absence should be the sensation that generates the feeling of your presence. It makes no sense, and yet it makes total sense.

 

Goodbye Kieran

I promised I’d publish my Eulogy to Kieran. I’m very grateful to Fr. Jonathan Boardman for kindly sending me his sermon, and to Fr. Toby Wright for his intercessions. Both were wonderful and added to the beauty of what was a really memorable occasion.

My Eulogy

What can I tell you about Kieran?

Well you will know now, if you didn’t know already, that he was a science-fiction geek.* Obviously, he loved Doctor Who. He also watched endless episodes of all the various versions of Star Trek; and I have lost count of the number of times that I had to watch the entire Star Wars series!

I can tell you the facts of his life. He was born in Colchester General Hospital on 9th July 1980 but was brought up in Peterborough. He went to Deacon’s School and then Peterborough Regional College, where he studied for his OND and HND qualifications in computing.

I can tell you that, when he was 20, he decided he’d had enough of Peterborough, packed a bag and took a train to Brighton, where he found a job working in the Sussex Hotel in Hove.

While he was living in Brighton, Kieran had a dreadful accident, falling from the Marine Parade and breaking his back. He spent his 22nd birthday in a coma but, according to his sister, Marie, on waking up he asked where his card from Graham Norton was!

I can tell you that Kieran held a variety of IT jobs, ending up working for Thomson’s Financial at Old Street in London, commuting in from his flat in Eastbourne. This is what he was doing when we met in 2007.

I can tell you that the day we met was the best day in both our lives. I’m not sure I used to believe in the concept of love at first sight, but this really is what happened to us. We knew, instantly, that we had each of us met our soul mate and the love of our lives. When the lease came up for renewal on his flat a mere five months after we met, there was no hesitation on either of our parts that the obvious thing was for him to move in with me. It was a decision that neither of us ever regretted.

I can tell you that Kieran changed a lot in the time we were together. I think everyone who has known Kieran over the past twelve years will have noticed by just how much he changed.

On a slightly less than serious note, I can tell you about how he changed in his culinary expertise. When we met he was, basically, living on a diet of burgers and pizza and never cooked. Indeed, he told me that he couldn’t cook. I well remember the first time I visited him in Eastbourne, looking in his cupboard to see what I might prepare for supper. Literally the only thing in the cupboard was a tin of foie gras. Well, at least he had taste.

How he changed. Once he’d moved to Maldon he started to cook supper when I was going to be late home. His Sunday roasts became an important fixture of our lives and were excellent. Barely six months after moving in with me, I came home to discover that he’d prepared home-made meat balls: hardly an easy thing to do, but they were delicious. That was when I asked him to marry me.

I will just add that there was a downside to Kieran’s newfound enthusiasm for cooking. There was the famous occasion when he served me roast lamb one Sunday lunchtime, with a variety of vegetables. Kieran always liked to have lots of different vegetables and, on this occasion, he had prepared green beans. I love green beans so you can imagine my confusion when I put a forkful of them in my mouth and couldn’t compute what was happening. I actually wondered whether I was being poisoned for a few seconds, until I realised that what he thought had been green beans were, in fact, green chillies. Imagine having a whole mouthful of those! A rush to the kitchen and gallons of water followed. When I accused him of trying to poison me, his response was “blast; it didn’t work.”  Then there was the state of the kitchen after he’d cooked, which always looked as though a bomb had hit it. And he had a total inability ever to put anything back in the same place, which meant I could never find anythingwhen it was my turn to cook. Often, when I was trying to find a particular implement or pan, I would mutter complaints under my breath. Being visually impaired meant that Kieran had excellent hearing, so he always heard my muttering; even from several rooms away! His standard response was “You love me!” Of course, there was no answer to that; particularly if he had come into the room and accompanied the statement with his magical smile.

I can also tell you, but you probably know this anyway, that it wasn’t just me who loved Kieran. Everyone loved him. What was there to not love? He was the sweetest, gentlest, kindest, most caring and most loving person I ever met. His concern for others, and for their problems, was immense. I know that there are quite a few people here who were touched by his care and compassion.

Right from the start, he looked after and protected me. His smile, which could melt the coldest heart at 100 paces, and his sense of fun was inimitable. We made each other laugh throughout our time together; surely the most important ingredient in any relationship?

Nor was it just me whom he reduced to giggles. One of the most common comments I’ve received from people after learning of his death was that he was “hilarious.” He really was, and his cheekiness frequently reduced people to laughter at the most inappropriate times.

I well remember one Sunday when we were singing Palestrina’s Missa Brevis at Mass. I’d been waxing lyrical during the rehearsal about how I thought the Sanctus was truly the song of the angels, with its cascade of voices entering one over the other and it’s joyous Osanna. Just as I was preparing to conduct it during the Mass, Katie, who was standing in front of Kieran, sort of exploded and collapsed into a heap. Kieran stood there looking angelic and I had no idea what had happened. It was only later, when Mass was ended, that Katie told me Kieran had lent forward just before we sang and had whispered “I’m going to Osanna all over you!”

I referred earlier to how Kieran changed over the past twelve years. It’s something that so many people have commented on, and I think it’s fair to say that he changed fundamentally over that time. When I first knew him, Kieran was beset by demons. He suffered terribly from extremely low self-esteem, borne of a profound sense of rejection earlier in life and, to an extent, frustration that he’d not been dealt a particularly good hand. But Kieran was one of the most determined people I ever met; determined to overcome the obstacles that life had placed before him. As far as he could, he never let the fact of his visual impairment hold him back.

An example of his determination could be seen in the way in which he took up piano lessons. He’d had these when he was young and had been frustrated that he’d not been able to continue them. Shortly after we met, he started having lessons and learnt the first of the Bach 48 preludes, which Chris played before the service, starting lessons from scratch and performing the prelude in concert in just six months. A truly impressive feat. Though he felt that he’d not had the opportunities or support that others have earlier in life he was determined to make up for this, which is why he was so enjoying his OU degree; something at which, incidentally, he was doing really well; consistently achieving marks in the 80s and 90s.

Perhaps more importantly, and certainly impressively, he decided that he wasn’t going to let his demons define him for his entire life. It’s true that he had a couple of years of counselling and also had therapy but, in the end, I believe it was his own determination that got him to a point where he managed to work it all out for himself. In our nearly twelve years together, Kieran turned from a timid, rather insecure person who hatedbeing thrown into new situations and loathed being put in the spotlight, into a confident, engaging and thoroughly entertaining man. He still had his black moments but he’d learnt for himself how to deal with them. People have told me that I helped him to become the confident person that we all knew at the end. I don’t know about that, but I’d like to think that I was able to provide an environment for him in which he was able to grow, develop and blossom.

What I can say with certainty is that he definitely changed me. I know, incontrovertibly, that I am a far, far better person now than I was before Kieran came into my life. Quite simply, he was my better half and I am blessed to have had him in my life. We all are.

*the coffin was a Tardis.

Kieran eating ice cream

Jonathan’s Sermon (note; parts of this are just headings, or aide memoires for Jonathan, rather than the full text given at the funeral. It does give a good idea of Jonathan’s wonderful address, however).

It’s not only our nation that can be divided into two kinds of people just now – its actually the entire world. So while I wouldn’t presume to think that every human being takes a position over a matter so divisive locally as Brexit – despite our innate national sense of self-importance most citizens of the world just ain’t botheredfor proof just look at the face – In spite of this I would still urge that today, globally, we all stand on one side of a significant divide or the other. I’m talking of course about  whether you privilege Samsung or Apple products.

 In the face of Kieran’s passion and expertise in all things IT and his consequent championing of the Galaxy Tablet my own blind loyalty to iPhone and iPad surely must have struck him as parallel to the position taken by an ignorant Brexiteer living in the fantasy world of Britain’s past greatness. O dear am I talking about Brexit again?….well it was a subject close to Kieran’s heart so perhaps I can be forgiven, and it is after all March 29th. Some people – I hesitate to say all people in lovely Essex – have been dreading this day on the calendar for over two years. But who could have predicted the way in which we gathered here today would all be facing a personal tragedy on the scale of a young life cut short at its most confident, at its most fruitful and at its most loved and loving? Personal loss of this nature puts so much into perspective.

 Amongst so much else to celebrate and remember with gratitude about Kieran he had in my experience the ability to hold to and act upon matters of fact as he truly found them to be – something that casts the character of those lazy creatures of habit we so often assume into the distinct shade.

 Why when having come to terms with your own sexuality shouldn’t you live it openly and with joy to the fullest extent? Kieran knew why: because lies and evasions suffocate and restrict growth.

 Why when having the love of a life partner who truly compliments you and makes you more fully the person you are shouldn’t you cleave to him with both gentleness and strength, in moments of difficulty as well as those of pleasure? Kieran knew why: because life is for the living and when someone is alongside you on the journey they deserve honesty and faithfulness, as you do in return.

 There was something so refreshingly and inspiringly honest in Kieran, something that I know we all admire; not only those of us who, like myself, think perhaps we have made too many compromises in life.

Human beings need and deserve love, and considering just how many of us there are on this planet there really ought to be enough to go round. But its truly amazing how often we feel the absence of love rather than its reassurance. Kieran was no different in that – human life and human character are frail earthen vessels that can too easily break. The value of the loves we experience can only truly be rated  when they are taken away, when we are sunk deep in a contemplation of their absence or loss. The temptation is to think that love is gone for ever.

The Song of Songs……..

Colin and Kieran

World divided into two kinds of people  ? Of faith and without faith?

I came across a Latin tag years ago which I have since treasured:                                                                                                                                                                                            

‘Bis vivit qui bene’ ‘The one who lives well lives twice’. Consonant as these words are with the spirit of ‘carpe diem‘ (gathering rose buds while we may, making the most of life’s little span), it is also an element of the philosophy which supports all the world’s religions. ‘Living well’, a Platonic philosophical concept, is an outward facing as well as self-referential principle. I thank God that in encountering the honest skepticism of someone like Kieran my own faith has been strengthened and my capacity to respect those of opposing conviction has increased. Where true charity is there love abounds.                                                  

 Bis vivit qui bene– ‘the one who lives well lives twice’. Hidden within this epigram there is, of course, the

Christian hope par excellence – resurrection. But I like the way it’s also open to appreciation by those of uncertain or indeed no faith at all. Such a one was the poet A.E.Housman, a teacher to the WWI generation of youth lost too early, lost like Kieran in their prime.

His collection A Shropshire Lad contains real treasure:

      From far, from eve and morning

            And yon twelve-winded sky,

      The stuff of life to knit me

            Blew hither: here am I.

 

      Now – for a breath I tarry

            Nor yet disperse apart –

      Take my hand quick and tell me,

            What have you in your heart.

 

      Speak now, and I will answer,

            How shall I help you, say.

      Ere to the world’s twelve quarters

            I take my endless way.

 

It is love and honesty then that unites humanity

Toby’s Intercessions

God of tenderness, the death of Kieran brings an emptiness into our lives.  We are separated from him and feel broken.

Give us confidence that he is safe in your divine garden of eternity and his life complete with you, and bring us together at the last to the wholeness and fullness of your presence in heaven, where your saints and angels enjoy you forever.

Lord in your mercy

Hear our prayer.

God of tenderness, we thank you for the gift of earthly love.  For Colin and Kieran’s love for each other and for the love of his family and friends. We know that loves ‘flashes are flashes of fire, a most vehement flame’. We pray that in the loss and pain that love may sustain and hold those who are left behind in our shock.  And we pray that Kieran may now know the eternal all-encompassing love which you offer to each and to all.

Lord in your mercy

Hear our prayer.

God of tenderness, we pray for those who mourn.  Be gentle to them in their grief. Show them the depths of your love, a glimpse of the kingdom of heaven. Spare them the torment of guilt and despair. Be with them as they weep beside the empty tomb of our risen saviour.

Lord in your mercy

Hear our prayer

God of us all, your love never ends.
When all else fails, you still are God.
We pray to you for one another in our need,
and for all, anywhere, who mourn with us this day.

To those who doubt, give light;
to those who are weak, strength;
to all who have sinned, mercy;
to all who sorrow, your peace.
Keep true in us the love with which we hold one another.

Lord, in your mercy

Hear our prayer

God, we are told that you are compassionate,
Today this is hard to believe.
God, we are told that you love us,
Today we do not feel loved.
God, we are told that we should offer you our praise and thanksgivings,
Today all we have to offer is anger and confusion.
God, despite all these feelings we turn to you,
Today there is no one else to turn to.God, hold us until we can believe again.

God, love us until we can feel your love again.

God, accept our anger and confusion until we can offer you praise and thanksgiving again.

God, our lives and our feelings rise and fall but you remain constant.

Help us to rest in your eternal changelessness.

Lord in your mercy

Hear our prayer.

Give us grace, in patience and understanding,
to listen to each other, and to help one another.
Supported by your strength
may our love for one another be deepened
by the knowledge of your love for us all
through Jesus Christ our Lord,
who taught us to pray with confidence:

Our Father,
Who art in heaven,
Hallowed be thy name,
Thy kingdom come,
Thy will be done, on earth as it is in heaven.
Give us this day our daily bread,
And forgive us our trespasses,
As we forgive those who trespass against us,
And lead us not into temptation,
But deliver us from evil.
For thine is the kingdom,
the power and the glory
Forever and ever. Amen.

Colin and Kieran Bradwell

Are the times finally changing?

It’s been a while since I wrote a blog. Partly, this is because I’ve been incredibly busy, but it’s also because I’ve been rather seduced by Twitter over recent months. It’s terrible easy to get drawn into a long online discussion (or argument) on that platform.

Now that we’ve just started another academic year and are all back to work, however, it seems a particularly appropriate time to write a new post. There’s certainly a lot to think about at present.

We hear that Boris Johnson is launching another leadership bid. That would appear to have been somewhat holed under the water by revelations of his private life last week, by the booing he received at the Oval on Saturday and, most importantly, by the extraordinarily ill-advised piece he wrote in the Telegraph about suicide vests. Personally, I can’t think of a more untrustworthy and less suitable candidate for the post of PM anywhere. I really hope his ambitions have been permanently damaged but he does appear to be made out of India rubber. Then again, there’s that prosecution for misconduct in public office…

Over the summer, all the foremost Brexiters (Rees-Mogg, Farage, Ian Duncan-Smith etc) have all made comments to the effect that they realise, and have always realised, that Brexit is going to make life much more difficult for the country. In the past 24 hours, Liam Fox, who is supposed to be leading us to the sunlight uplands of new global trading partnerships (that’s not going so well, is it?) has admitted that he “can’t promise life will be rosy after Brexit.” All of which begs the question of why on earth the government is so doggedly pursuing the wretched thing. Any ideas? No, me neither.

Then we discover that the Maybot and her henchmen are trying to frustrate the case brought by ex-pats living in the EU from ever getting to court because “it was widely known that Leave was breaking the rules.” What ?! That’s some sort of acceptable defence? And there was I thinking we lived in a democracy governed by the rule of law. We seem to have sunk to the level of the lowest tin-pot third world dictatorship. How much worse can things possibly get? Then again, I have had that thought a thousand times since 23rd June 2016.

But before we get too depressed, there do appear to be some brighter prospects ahead (I know, I am an eternal optimist but hear me out). There has been rumour and counter rumour swirling around for months now but it really does seem as though there is something afoot in the political realignment stakes.

I’ve always admired Vince Cable, and his talk the other day of a new “movement” seemed extraordinarily positive. I know that there are party members who do not like the idea of allowing people to become supporters but even long-term members admit that the LibDems are probably irrevocably damaged following their ill-advised coalition with the Tories. As a LibDem member myself (albeit one who resigned over the coalition and only rejoined following the terrible 2015 election result) it seems the only sensible way ahead.

I rejoined the party because I believe passionately that we need a moderating force in British politics. With the two main parties becoming ever more extreme, and pulling themselves apart in the process, it really is time for a new centrist movement. Cable’s use of that term, rather than talk of a new party, is incredibly interesting and exciting, because it provides for the sensible MPs from both main parties to coalesce around a new movement whose main aim is to stop Brexit rather than being seen as “traitors” to their current parties. It does seem as though, finally, some MPs at least are putting country before party. Whether a new party emerges eventually out of all this is a subject for another time. The only thing that is important at present is to stop Brexit. Once that’s done, everything else can be looked at.

Whatever that “everything else” involves, I sincerely hope it is not a return to business as usual. Our system is clearly broken. Indeed, the inability of our system to function at all over the past two years has made us an international laughing stock. A huge overhaul and modernisation is long-overdue. The archaic and arcane nature of our system is laughable. That MPs can talk a perfectly sensible piece of legislation out of time just because they don’t understand it (up skirting) is a disgrace.

If there is anything positive about Brexit (and this is the only thing) at least it has made us aware of just how broken our system is. A realignment, coupled with a proportional voting system and a move out of the Palace of Westminster could finally see us become a modern, mature democracy. By the way, that last is probably too much to hope for but we really should be thinking about holding parliamentary debates in a modern horse-shoe chamber rather than the adversarial one that dates back to the eighteenth century! Even better: move to a modern parliament building somewhere other than London. The North, for instance. Just think how many benefits that would bring!

Thank you for reading my ramblings. I’ll work myself up for another outpouring soon!

Colin

 

Whence democracy?

There’s been a lot in the press this week about a second referendum. One minute it seems that Jeremy Corbyn might be warming to the idea, the next it’s totally ruled out. Even Kier Starmer, who had seemed to be the voice of reason in the shadow cabinet as far as Brexit is concerned, has ruled a second referendum out. Remainers are in despair. Who speaks for them? The only truly pro-EU party seems to be the LibDems (apart from the Greens) but they are failing to make any headway. Indeed, that fact appears to justify a lot of Momentum-ites in their antipathy to a second referendum. “The LibDems campaigned specifically on a ticket for a second referendum last year and failed to make a breakthrough, which is a clear indication that no-one wants a second referendum.”

Well, yes and no. No-one wants to re-run the referendum. What would be the point of that? All the same old ill-informed and misleading arguments would be rehearsed again and the country would remain as divided as it is now, possibly more so.

Yet, with the lamentable lack of any sort of morality within the present government, an inability, or unwillingness, to actually oppose by the official opposition and a House of Commons that seems positively supine in its ability to simply role over and do what the Maybot says, what are those of us who believe that the country is being led in a disastrously mistaken direction supposed to do? And this doesn’t even begin to take account of all the very real problems, such as collapsing public services (most spectacularly the Health Service), the housing crisis and a huge lack of resources for education; all of which issues are slipping almost unnoticed under the radar while our incompetent government bangs on about Brexit at the cost of all else.

First of all, we should never have had the referendum in the first place. It was an appalling abrogation of responsibility on the part of David Cameron to even suggest it. Everyone knows that referendums are “device of dictators and demagogs”, to quote Thatcher, who was herself quoting Attlee (and I can’t imagine I’ll ever quote Thatcher again). Why have successive governments steadfastly refused to allow one on hanging? Because they know that the result would be its reintroduction. If parliamentarians can possess scruples about such things, knowing that mob rule (which is essentially what a referendum is) will not lead to good decision making, why on earth did they go along with the EU referendum? Political expediency is the answer and is also the reason why politicians are held in such contempt, which is not good for democracy.

David Cameron, in his determination to gain a majority, sacrificed any integrity he may have had in calling the referendum and it backfired spectacularly. Many people have commented on the fact that the referendum turned into a right wing coup, which is exactly what it was. If Cameron had had any backbone, he would have stood up to UKIP and told them that their abhorrent ideology was wrong. Instead, in a naked attempt to steal their supporters, he simply adopted their policies. Not only did this lose the referendum, it unleashed a particularly unpleasant strain of nationalism and racism that I’m not sure has ever been seen previously in the UK (the nearest thing I can think of were Moseley’s Blackshirts and the Cable Street riots; though that was a movement, not a philosophy of a large percentage of the public). Then, having lost the referendum, DC simply walks off into the sunset, leaving May, Davis, Johnson, Fox et al to take the reigns and usher in the most right wing government in living memory.

How did this happen? How have we ended up with an opposition that seems willing to just roll over and accept what the government says? “The will of the people” is a nonsense. It’s nothing of the sort. Corbyn, it seems to me, simply wants to get into power at any cost so that he can create his utopian socialist Britain. The really sad part of this is that I would probably be supporting him in this, were it not for his stance on Brexit, which is nationalistic, wrong-headed and anti-democratic.

Do we really get the government we deserve, as people seem fond of saying these days? Or is it that there are simply not the people around with a strong sense of morality and a desire to do what they can for the common good? Where are the Clement Attlees, the Harold Wilsons, the Rab Butlers, yes even the Churchills? Look at the makeup of any cabinet up to the 1970s (of any hue) and they were filled with real statesmen. People who went into politics because they really believed that they could make a difference. What have we got now? A self-serving bunch of mediocre politicians who seem to be interested only in their own futures. I know that there are good, hardworking MPs who do still believe in the common good but, sadly, this doesn’t get them into government. It seems that, to get into government, you simply have to be a mate of Boris Johnson or some other twit with a sense of entitlement. Toby Young eventually gets forced to resign because of huge public pressure, yet Ben Bradley, who posted equally appalling comments (if not more so) “is not going to be sacked”.

So no, a second referendum is not the answer. A new or “fresh” referendum on the final terms might be. Indeed it is probably absolutely necessary. Since Cameron set us on this path where “the people decide” it must be the people deciding on the final destination, surely? It would be far better for MPs, whom we know are overwhelmingly in favour of remaining in the EU (something like 75%), to rediscover their moral compasses and vote against a bad deal or no deal at all. This would precipitate an election, where a proper debate, with real facts (no £350million on buses) would be needed. Then the whole sorry business could be put to bed. Since that is not going to happen, a new referendum is probably the only answer.

What a mighty mess. Yet what Brexit has done, apart from the disaster of its own existence, is to expose the parlous state of democracy in our country. When something as important as Brexit is reduced to schoolboy yah-boo-sucks in the House of Commons, there has to be something really rotten at the core of our system.

Two things need to change if we’re to have any chance of having something that even vaguely resembles real democracy in the UK. The first past the post electoral system needs to be thrown in the dustbin and replaced with a truly democratic proportional system; and the House of Commons itself needs remodelling. With the Palace of Westminster needing major surgery, now would be the ideal time for the Commons to move out and into a modern, horse-shoe shaped debating chamber. The yah-boo-sucks mode of “debate” would disappear instantly. It doesn’t lead to sensible decision making (after all, we don’t all disagree with each other all the time) and it really is time that parliamentarians grew up and started behaving like adults.

A third change would be the reform of the House of Lords, which would become impossible to avoid with a more modern lower house.

Sadly, I am not holding my breath.

Welcome to Indoor Voice!

This is the post excerpt.

You may be wondering why I’ve called this blog Indoor Voice. On the other hand, you might not be bothered at all. If so, tough, because I’m going to tell you!

Those of you who know me (and, perhaps more importantly, my partner Kieran) well, will understand. For those of you who don’t, here’s the explanation:

Having spent my entire life working on and releasing my voice, it’s probably fair to say I am not a particularly quiet person. I think I speak at a normal level. Kieran thinks I’m loud. For instance, I might ask him “Kieran, would you like a cup of tea?” to which he frequently replies, “I’m standing next to you. You don’t need to shout.”

Now what Kieran doesn’t realise is that I am not, by any stretch of the imagination, shouting. I put his inability to distinguish between shouting and a normal conversational use of the voice down to his having led a sheltered existence before meeting me.

His other favourite response to my addressing him is “use your indoor voice” or, more usually just, “indoor voice!” Clearly, the “!” is implied in his use of the imperative. I don’t know whether he thinks it will make any difference. It’s probably just exasperation.

So there you have it. Apparently I’m loud and I like to express myself in a dramatic fashion. “Why do you always have to be so dramatic?” is another favourite of Kieran’s responses. What a ridiculous question. Doesn’t he realise I’m an opera singer?!!

I’m sure there are plenty of you reading this post (assuming that anyone is actually reading it) who can identify with poor Kieran’s predicament. Those of us of a dramatic bent think the way we speak and express ourselves is completely normal. It’s the rest of you who are abnormal. And would you please stop mumbling?!

Anyway, the reason for starting this blog is, again, to keep Kieran happy. He’s been telling me for ages (years?) that I should start a blog so that I can write my rants somewhere where people who actually want to read them can go out of their own free will. Rants? Me?!

Expect lots of political thought and comment (now you really would be surprised if I wasn’t going to write anything about politics). Don’t expect lots of fluffy pictures of cats (though there may be some of those. Cleo is, after all, very cute). There will also be comments about education and, of course, music and the arts.

There’s a political blog itching to get out but I’ll save that until later. First of all, I just want to welcome you with this initial, “Hello World” blog.

Happy New Year!

Colin

BTW this picture of waves is totally irrelevant. I’ll work out how to remove it next time. It is rather relaxing though, isn’t it?

post